Excavating the nuggets - chord tone study 2

Well, this article was written a couple months back, but was out for just a couple of days before being withdrawn. The reason is that the author of the reviewed books pointed that they had been unavailable for a while, and new editions have appeared in the meantime. And the changes were not just about the looks, but the progression of steps in the overall practicing approach have been modified as well (for the better, IMHO). I wasted no time ordering the new ones, so here is the updated version! 

the oldies

In the previous post you could learn something about the benefits of working on chord tones as the means of making progress on the instrument. This time, I will point you to what, IMHO, is the best starting point on this path - the books written by Phil Mann. He happens to be a phenomenal instructor, and you can find more about his bio and professional work as a bassist on the man's website.

Mann's approach to the subject is very thorough and done in a step-by-step manner, which means easy to understand and follow, although you WILL HAVE to put in the work, no doubt about it. He intends to cover the material through a series of book, and so far two have come out:

Vol 1. An Excavation of the Humble Triad

Vol 2. The Transcendence from Intent to Implementation

So, the first volume, as you may have guessed, is concerned with the triads that serve as the foundation for all other harmonic structures in music. Mann offers the theoretical fundamentals as they pertain to the material in the book, and then proceeds to the treatment of the topic - major, minor, diminished, and augments triads. Each chord quality is shown and practiced in all of its inversions, and at one point the major triad is also run through its permutation, but once you get the idea other qualities ought to be put through the paces, too. The major, minor and diminished structures are then done as two-octave studies; and finally, melodic applications are demonstrated on two staple chord progressions (ii-V-I and I-IV-V). Whew, a lot of stuff! 

the foundation

The material is presented exquisitely well presented through standard notation and tablature, where the latter format is necessary, i.e. to lay out the structures on the fingerboard. In the melodic applications, however, the tablature is (rightly) omitted, so you can work on your own options on the instrument. 

Before moving to the next book, I will briefly offer a personal insight. When isolated, any of the triads can be drilled in on of two ways - vertically or horizontally. Take them as two-string shapes and go though the cycle of fourths either in a chosen 5-fret section on the fingerboard (vertical), or with the bottom note on a single string (horizontal).

The second volume deals with tetrachords, i.e. 7th arpeggios, which are four-tone structures, and the approach follows the same overall path as with triads. Mann tackles the ones found in diatonic major and minor tonalities, i.e. major, minor, dominant, and minor 7b5.  Naturally, there is more work to be done because there are more inversions to address, but if you had done diligent work with the first book, this one should not be a problem. 

the challenge

However, the 7th chords are not covered in as much detail and as small incremental steps as the triads in book 1. And there is a good reason... The second half of this volume is where the really musical effort takes place, or if you so prefer - where the rubber meets the road. Namely, Mann gives a brief but practical explanation of the II-V harmonic progression and why it is important, as taken from the bridge of Rhythm Changes, and then goes into the application of various shapes and forms of 7th chords previously covered over this ubiquitous harmonic device. This segment is done in both major and minor tonalities, again. He first does it with the shapes in the "as is" option, so you can develop the understanding of the overall harmonic form and get your ear to recognize the function of each chord used; and then gets to what is probably the main point of the method - voice leading! 

Why is this important? Well, because in a real musical situation you (hopefully) want your lines to be smooth and not sounding like mere exercises. However, in order to get there, you DO need to have the exercises firmly under your belt, or, even better, under your fingers and in your ears. The foreword to the book, written by Matt Bokulic, addresses this gap between the purely academic approach to practice and creative expression in performance, while Mann himself states very convincingly in the book that while the early material may be "[...] initially tedious to comprehend, the concluding results will be enthralling - as you'll be able to convey and incredibly efficient portrayal of Gershwin's Rhythm Changes [...] and all in the full knowledge that your skill set can easily be implemented in hundreds of subsequent compositions". 

The last section of the book moves to the implementation of the material, and your newly found command of it, over the harmonic structure of a typical jazz blues form in all keys. Again, there is a lot of work to be done over a long time, but you will be comforted by the knowledge that you are on the right path, following a proven method. 

If you would like to get some sense of Mann's teaching style, he has several videos freely available on his Youtube channel, and this one is on the topic of major scale harmonization in triads:

All in all, having seen his courses on the Scott's Bass Lessons portal, articles in Bass Player and after perusing these books, Phil Mann is one of my favorite bass teachers out there, and I really look forward to his future contributions in the field. 

Isolated bass...lost opportunity?

 Besides music, and bass in particular, my other (the first, as the matter of fact) is martial arts, and I have noted a strange disparity of how instructors in both fields have tackled the problem of staying put in our homes, without access to our regular "working avenues" of training and gigging. Namely, the number of martial art coaches and instructors who have offered either individual or group sessions via Zoom or similar live streaming outlets has been staggering. With music professionals, not really. Maybe it is because in case of musicians online teaching through live sessions has been a rather normal thing for quite some time, even before the pandemic outburst. 

However, my impressions is that the top echelon of performing professionals has missed a good opportunity here. See, the Berklee bas department did do a few events of the panel-discussion kind, but in all honest, those weren't much educational in terms of specific material or approaches to practicing. The thing is, hosting an online conference with a similar attitude as doing a clinic can be beneficial in several ways. 

To begin with, there are a lot of people out there who would love to have lessons from the top-level "so and so" musicians, but as the potential clients they are either intimidated or thinking there is no way those payers would even consider giving lessons. Conducting a free or affordable online clinic is  great way to show that they are accessible as instructors, and also to demonstrate their teaching chops. Here is a good example of how it can be done - Phil Mann did a series of lessons through Facebook live streams, and later put them on his Youtube channel With Bass in Mind. 

Adam Nitti is another monster player who has recently started doing similar sessions, with his excellent clinic on ear training. Choosing to do it via Zoom had the advantage of attendees being able to react immediately and establish good rapport, with feedback from both sides. On the other hand, just like the previous gentleman, Nitti is a veteran music educator in parallel with his recording and performing career, so he understands the need to keep in touch with his audience. 

As he matter of fact, even the rare cats that are actually already fully scheduled with their private lessons have understood the value of such public events. Anthony Wellington of the Bassology fame. The man who does 10+ private sessions on a daily basis still offers these opportunities for the potential clients who cannot get in queue or pay his regular fees. That helps spread the word and make sure he will never run out of work. 

And also...well, that's about it. I don't know what it is that makes the bass professionals shun those avenues of work, and that's a shame. I was hoping to be able and see some of them teach in this format, but it wasn't meant to be. 

Or maybe I am wrong and uninformed about such events taking place, in which case - please correct me!